Best Coffee Syrups: Our Top 11 Picks Taste Tested and Reviewed

17 min read JAN 22, 2023

If you want to improve your coffee-making skills, syrups are the way to go. But with so many options available on the market today, what should you look for when choosing one? In this article, we'll guide you through our top picks and provide tips on reading ingredient labels. So come join us as we explore how best to brew that perfect cup of coffee.

Our Top 11 Best Coffee Syrups Picks

DaVinci Gourmet Classic Coffee Syrup

Since its inception, DaVinci has been perfecting the flavor of its coffee syrups for well over three decades. Extending this time frame only allowed them to enhance and diversify their taste selection even further.

If you're looking to try something different in your coffee, DaVinci offers a wide array of classic and unusual flavors - from the tried-and-true caramel, chocolate, and Irish cream syrups to more daring choices like habanero or peach chipotle. While this spicy variety might not be for everyone, those who enjoy it will surely appreciate its unique flavor. All of their syrups are made with cane sugar as a sweetener; however, they also have lines using other sweeteners, such as sugar-free options.

With an unwavering commitment to natural ingredients, DaVinci prides itself on offering only the purest and cleanest products. Moreover, all of its syrups are certified kosher, which promises that you won't find any suspicious components or dubious substances among them.

  • Sweetener is derived from cane sugar
  • They offer a range of sugar-free options
  • A huge flavor selection is available
  • Packaging comes in 25.4 fluid ounces sizes

Jordan's Skinny Syrups

After a long history of crafting cocktail syrups that spanned 12 years, this legendary brand moved into the realm of coffee syrups and quickly became renowned worldwide.

Jordan's Skinny Syrups are a guilt-free pleasure, containing no sugar, calories or carbs. You can indulge in the delicious variety of flavors without worrying about your diet, keto and gluten-free diets included. Spice up your coffee with one of these syrups for an entertaining twist on taste.

Indulge in classic coffee flavors like mocha, hazelnut and caramel when you purchase this exquisite little set. But if you're after something out of the ordinary, Jordan's Skinny Syrups have got your back.

I'm particularly fond of glazed donuts and toasted marshmallows. They are my absolute favorites.

  • Sucralose is the main sweetening agent
  • Sugar-free options are available
  • A variety of flavors are available to suit all tastes.
  • The standard packaging size comes in at 25.4 fluid ounces.

Torani Fall Winter Syrup 4 Pack

With nearly a century of experience, it's no wonder that Torani is one of the most renowned names in syrup. It certainly stands out amongst this list of big-name companies.

With an astonishing selection of over 150 flavors, ranging from nutty to fruity, Torani is sure to have syrup for everyone. It's no surprise that the brand has earned its place as a favorite amongst worldwide coffee lovers.

Torani syrup is made using only natural ingredients, and none of the most common allergens, such as peanuts, tree nuts, dairy, soy or eggs, are present in any of their products.

This line of products uses cane sugar as a sweetener, while the sugar-free alternatives utilize Sucralose and ace-K instead.

The Fall Winter syrup pack is the perfect way to get into the holiday spirit with its classic cold-weather flavors like pumpkin pie, peppermint, salted caramel and brown sugar cinnamon. But if you're feeling more daring this season, why not try butterscotch or Italian eggnog?

  • Sweetener is derived from cane sugar
  • There's an array of sugar-free options
  • The flavor range is extensive
  • Standard packaging size per product comes in at 25.4 fluid ounces

Upouria Coffee Syrup Variety Pack

Though Upouria may not offer many flavours, they provide the most iconic and sought-after coffee flavorings.

This variety pack is the best of all worlds. You'll get to enjoy beloved flavors like mocha, French vanilla and caramel. Plus, you don't have to go through the hassle of buying individual pumps; three are already included in your purchase - talk about a sweet deal.

For those of you who are conscious about your caloric intake, each serving contains approximately 90 calories.

Although the sugar-free range is not extensive, you still have two delectable options to choose from French Vanilla and Caramel. To sweeten these syrups, they use Sucralose, a safe artificial sweetener.

  • The sweetener of choice is sugar
  • They also offer sugar-free alternatives
  • A limited range of flavors is available
  • Products come in 25.4 fluid ounces packaging size

Holy Kakow Cafe Organic

This Oregon-based company is one of the few organic syrup brands. Their products are non-GMO and certified by multiple independent organizations. For the health-conscious, Holy Kakow Café organic flavored syrups are a godsend. These products contain no additives, preservatives or artificial flavors; they only feature natural ingredients. As if that wasn't enough, their syrups are also gluten-free, vegan and Kosher-friendly.

Kakow has an impressive selection of organic coffee syrups, crafted with only the finest responsibly-sourced ingredients and packaged in elegant glass bottles.

They offer classic flavors like vanilla and hazelnut and unique tastes such as lavender and rose - all sweetened by organic evaporated cane juice, which is made from sugar cane but retains more nutritional value than traditional table sugar.

If you find liquid separation occurring in your bottle, don't be alarmed; this happens naturally due to its natural composition, so just give it a shake before use.

  • The sweetener used is organic evaporated cane juice
  • There is no sugar-free option
  • A decent range of flavors is available
  • Standard packaging size at 25.4 fluid ounces

Ghirardelli Coffee Sauce

For those of you who are looking for a decadent coffee experience, then Ghirardelli is your go-to brand. Their coffee sauces feature bold flavors and luxurious textures that will easily elevate any cup of coffee to something extraordinary.

Ghirardelli presents a luxurious 5-bottle set of syrup specifically designed to enhance the flavor of espresso drinks.

Despite its thick, sauce-like consistency and premium gold packaging, this product does not offer any sugar-free options or suit those with allergies as it is manufactured in a facility that processes tree nuts, eggs and milk. As such, traces of any of these ingredients may be found in the syrup.

Nevertheless, its rich flavor can truly elevate any espresso-based beverage and make it even more delicious.

  • Sweetened with the natural sweetness of fructose
  • Limited range of flavors
  • Standard 16-fluid ounce packaging
  • No sugar-free alternatives

Starbucks Naturally Flavored Coffee Syrup

Starbucks has finally answered the popular demand and made their syrups available to everyone with this variety pack.

Starbucks is one of the most popular coffee brands around, and for a good reason. Their syrups are incredibly flavorful, versatile and conveniently packaged in standard 25.4-fluid ounce sizes.

This set contains three of their most beloved flavors: sweet, rich vanilla; smooth, buttery caramel; and strong, nutty hazelnut, along with "sugar" as a sweetener - but no sugar-free alternative yet, unfortunately.

Each serving adds around 90 calories to whatever drink you make at home. With these three flavors, you can create a ton of your favorite Starbucks drinks right at home.

The quality of the flavor is spot-on, so you won't miss out on the real thing. Whether it's for yourself or someone special, this variety pack has all the flavor and sweetness you need to make delicious coffee house drinks.

  • Sweeteners: Pure sugar.
  • Sugar-free options: Not available.
  • Flavor selection: Restricted range.
  • Typical packaging size: 12.17 fluid ounces per container.

Monin Gourmet Flavorings Premium Coffee Collection

Monin is a well-known name in the gourmet coffee syrup industry, and their premium collection does not disappoint. Monin Gourmet Flavorings offer premium flavorings that add an unequalled level of sophistication to any beverage.

Monin is a renowned brand creating high-quality syrups with an array of unique flavors, from hickory smoke to golden turmeric. It provides natural GMO, dairy, gluten, and kosher-certified natural ingredients, plus 15 sugar-free options for health-conscious consumers.

With such a diverse selection of flavours, Monin offers something delicious for everyone without guilt. From classic favourites like hazelnut and vanilla to more unusual flavours, you can experiment with various recipes to find the perfect combinations. Whether you're stirring up something special for yourself or adding a little sweetness to your drinks menu, Monin is sure to have what you need.

With quality assurance and an impressive range of flavour choices, Monin syrups are ideal for indulgence without compromise.

  • The sweetener used is pure cane sugar
  • Plenty of sugar-free options.
  • Huge selection of flavors
  • The packaging size is a 25.4 fluid-ounce bottle

Wholesome Yum Keto Coffee Syrup

Wholesome Yum Keto Coffee Syrup is the perfect choice for those on a ketogenic diet and looking for a way to add sweetness to their drinks without compromising flavor.

Wholesome Yum's syrup offers only two flavors, vanilla and hazelnut, but they stand out from the competition due to their natural sweeteners, monk fruit extract and allulose.

Not only are these syrups safe for diabetics, children and pets alike, but there are no calories or carbs.

The packaging is cute, too - although it does come in a small size with around 12 servings per bottle.

All this makes Wholesome Yum an ideal choice for those on strict diets who want to enjoy their coffee without compromising health goals.

Unfortunately, with only two flavors, the selection falls short compared to other syrups on the market; running out can mean a lot of online shopping unless you buy in bulk.

  • Products are sweetened with monk fruit extract and allulose
  • The flavor range is limited.
  • The sugar-free option is available
  • Standard packaging sizes come in 12 fluid ounces

Liquid Planet Organic Coconut Coffee Syrup

Liquid Planet Organic Coconut Coffee Syrup is a great choice for those looking to go organic.

The syrup is made with USDA-certified organic coconut sugar and flavored with natural extracts. It's non-GMO, gluten-free and vegan - plus, it has no added preservatives or artificial colors.

These syrups are perfect for adding flavor to your coffee, ice cream and pastries. There's a wide selection of seven flavors - coconut, almond, hazelnut Irish creme raspberry, caramel and vanilla syrup – all made with natural ingredients without any artificial flavoring or preservatives.

Although these syrups have an extended shelf-life due to the organic cane sugar content, they contain some sugar, so those on a diet might want to opt out of this range.

However, if you buy the syrup and find it has settled, shake it up for a uniform mixture. This is an excellent syrup range to make your home recipes special.

  • The sweetener used is all-natural organic cane sugar
  • Decent range of flavors
  • Packaged in 25.4 fluid-ounce containers
  • No sugar-free options are available

Amoretti Premium Classic Syrups

Amoretti Premium Classic Syrups are the ideal choice for those looking for exceptional quality and taste. These syrups provide a unique mix of natural flavors and sweeteners to bring you the most delicious, high-end syrups out there. Perfect for coffee, tea, cocktails, and more, each flavor offers its own unique aroma and taste experience.

Amoretti is committed to providing top-notch products that elevate your beverage experiences. With various flavors such as classic Vanilla, Salted Caramel, Chocolate Fudge and Hazelnut available in multiple sizes tailored to individual needs, Amoretti Premium Classic Syrups are the ideal choice for creating the perfect cup of coffee or indulgent drink. These syrups provide a rich flavor profile with just the right amount of sweetness so you can enjoy a full-bodied taste sensation every time.

High-quality ingredients combined with an all-natural production process make Amoretti Premium Classic Syrups stand out from the rest. With no added preservatives or artificial flavors, these syrups are a surefire way to add premium quality and amazing flavor to your favorite drinks. Versatile and convenient, you can use Amoretti Premium Classic Syrups in any recipe for the utmost enjoyment of each sip.

  • The sweetener used is cane sugar
  • Huge range of delicious flavors
  • Sugar-free options are available.
  • Each package is 25.4 fluid ounces.

What You Need To Know Before Buying A Coffee Syrup

When selecting the right coffee syrup, there is more to consider than just flavor. Be sure to examine different brands and their ingredients, as these can vary significantly. To help you make an informed choice, here are some key factors to keep in mind when choosing your perfect coffee syrup.

Which Sweetener Is Used?

Although coffee syrups are meant to be sweet, this doesn't necessarily imply that sugar needs to be the main component. A vast array of ingredients can replace it, such as corn syrup, fructose, dextrose and cane sugar - all derived from natural sources. However, even though these may come from nature does not mean they all have similar impacts on our bodies.

Cane sugar is a significantly healthier option, especially in its raw form. It is lower in calories than other sugars and provides essential amino acids and minerals while containing antioxidants that promote overall health.

We are all familiar with table sugar, but you may not know that this sweetener originates from sugar beets. Regrettably, the process of refining it requires bone char - making not only a nutrient-deficient product but also one unsuitable for vegetarians and vegans alike.

Next, artificial sweeteners offer a potent sweetness while boasting absolutely no calories. In fact, they are thousands of times sweeter than sugar.

You may be asking yourself, how is that even possible?

You may be familiar with the fact that our tongues house receptors that send signals to our brains, allowing us to recognize and distinguish flavors.

Artificial sweeteners offer a taste that activates our sweetness receptors just like sugar does, without calories. Our bodies cannot digest these sweeteners and, as a result, can't break them down, so they don't contain any calories.

Despite their bad reputation, not all artificial sweeteners are the same; Sucralose and aspartame are amongst the most widely used.

Numerous studies suggest that Sucralose can potentially improve digestion and immunity, although scientific evidence is still pending. On a positive note, there appear to be no known adverse effects of its consumption.

In contrast, aspartame has been associated with numerous health problems like cancer and cardiovascular diseases. However, there is no scientific evidence to support the claims yet. Therefore, it's not the wisest option for a sweetener.

In conclusion, when selecting your coffee syrup, it's important to think about the type of sweetener that is being used. Natural options such as cane sugar are excellent choices for those who want to keep their health in check while still enjoying a delicious cup of coffee.

Difference Between Coffee Syrups and Other Types Of Flavored Syrups

Coffee Syrup is specially created for coffee drinks and is intended to be added on top of or mixed within a hot cup of coffee.

Its capability to dissolve effortlessly in hot and cold beverages separates it from other flavored syrup. It is also specifically formulated to be less sweet than other syrups, allowing it to blend in with the coffee's natural flavors.

Here are some other types of flavored syrups you may come across:

Cocktail Syrup

Crafted for use with mixed drinks, both alcoholic and non-alcoholic, cocktail syrups easily dissolve in cold beverages yet do not mix as well in hot ones. In other words, you can get away with using them to make iced coffee but they might not be the optimal choice when it comes to creating your favorite hot coffee drinks.

Cooking Syrup

This type of flavored syrup is designed to be used in various beverages, including coffee. However, it should be noted that these syrups likely contain more calories than traditional coffee-flavoured syrups do. Make sure you consider this when deciding what type of syrup will best fit your needs.

Agave Nectar

This syrup has a distinct molasses flavor with an underlying hint of caramel. The darker the color, the more intense its sweet yet light taste. High in fructose but low GI, this natural alternative to sugar serves as a brilliant flavoring without being too overpowering.

3 Must Try Coffee Syrup Drink Ideas

Congratulations. You've found the ideal syrup for your coffee. Now it's time to think about using this delicious flavor in some classic beverages. To get your creative juices flowing, check out these delectable drink ideas that are easy to prepare at home.

Hot Peppermint Mocha

This festive beverage will make your taste buds feel like it's Christmas all year round. Don't let the holidays hold you back from enjoying this delicious refreshment any day of the week. Here's what you'll need to create this special treat:

  • 2 tbsps of cocoa powder,
  • 2 shots of espresso,
  • 1 cup steamed milk
  • 2tbsps peppermint syrup
  • Whipped cream
  • chocolate sauce
  • mini chocolate chips for decoration

To create this delicious treat, simply follow the steps below:

Begin by adding two tablespoons of cocoa powder to your cup.

Mix in two shots of espresso until the mixture is smooth and consistent.

Continue stirring as you add peppermint syrup and steamed milk for a delightful blend.

Finish off with whipped cream topped with chocolate drizzle, giving it an extra touch of sweetness that can be complemented with mini chocolate chips if desired.

Beat the heat with a refreshing iced peppermint mocha. Simply replace steamed milk with cold and add some ice cubes - you'll be sipping your chilled beverage in no time.

Pumpkin Spice Latte

Nothing beats the warmth and comfort of a homemade pumpkin spice latte on a cold winter day. This delicious treat is easy to make with just a few simple ingredients.

Here's what you'll need:

  • 2 tbsps of pumpkin spice syrup
  • Three-fourths cup steamed milk
  • One shot espresso
  • A few cinnamon sticks
  • Whipped cream
  • Ground cinnamon

Now that you have all the necessary components, here is what you must do next:

Add two tablespoons of pumpkin spice syrup to your cup to create a tantalizing pumpkin spice beverage. Combine it with a shot of freshly brewed espresso and stir until fully blended. Next, add steamed milk for extra creaminess and top off the concoction with whipped cream and cinnamon dusting - don't forget to garnish with an alluring cinnamon stick. Enjoy this easy-to-make delight that's sure to satisfy your sweet tooth.

Caffe Mocha

The simplest recipes often produce the most popular drinks when it comes to caffeinated beverages. Take, for instance, a classic Caffe Mocha - you need two key ingredients, and you're good to go.

  • Two tbsps of chocolate syrup
  • Two shots of espresso
  • One cup of steamed milk
  • One cup of heavy whipping cream
  • One teaspoonful of vanilla extract

Now that you have all the necessary components, let's move on to the next step:

To make a delicious mocha, begin by stirring 2 tablespoons of chocolate syrup into an empty cup. Next, craft two espresso shots and pour the mixture over the syrup. Carefully fill up the rest of your cup with steamed milk until it is almost full. Take out a bowl and add some whipping cream and vanilla extract to create whipped topping for your drink - this should take no more than 5 minutes. Finally, top off your mocha with this creamy delight for an extraordinary beverage experience.

This recipe is incredibly simple, and you can't go wrong with a classic café mocha.

The Final Verdict

Enjoying your beloved cup of joe without going out has never been so convenient. Making sure you have a variety of coffee syrups on hand is the key to making delicious drinks at home. Don't be afraid to try something new - plenty of unique and scrumptious flavors will tantalize your taste buds. So pick up your favorite ingredients and start brewing today - you won't regret it.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What type of milk should I use for my coffee creations?

It all depends on your preference - some may prefer to use whole, almond, oat, or even soy milk. Experiment with different types and find the one that suits you best.

How much syrup should I add to my drink?

It depends on the intensity of flavor you want to achieve. Start by adding two tablespoons and adjust accordingly.

Can I make coffee-based cocktails at home with coffee syrups?

Absolutely. Many boutique cocktail bars use coffee syrups as mixers and flavor enhancers. You can create anything from a classic espresso martini to an iced peppermint mocha. The possibilities are endless.

Is it possible to make cold beverages at home with coffee syrups?

Yes, you can easily craft delicious frappes or smoothies using coffee syrups for an extra zing of flavor. Try blending some of your favorite ingredients and enjoy a cold beverage that will leave you feeling energized and refreshed.

How can I store my coffee syrups for maximum shelf life?

Make sure to keep your coffee syrups in a dry, room-temperature environment. If you plan to store them for an extended period, consider freezing them in airtight containers or glass jars.

Are there any substitutes for coffee syrup if I'm out of ingredients?

Yes, some may substitute regular sugar or honey for their desired sweetness levels. You can also try adding other flavors, like caramel or hazelnut, to make unique drinks that will tantalize your taste buds.

Check out Lifeboost Coffee Espresso.


Drop a Comment

All comments are moderated before being published